The Pie Monger
**add meringue to some styles for $2.00 more--call in and ask**
***Please order 24 hours in advance for Cream Pies. We make them fresh just for you!!!
Key Lime Pie-$16.95
Make the trip to the Florida Key's without leaving the state. This creamy pie has a wonderful twist of of Key Lime Juice that for a great sweet and tart combination. Topped with homemade whipped cream, you won't be disappointed.
Push-Up Pop Pie-$16.95
Remember those warm Summer days when you used to go to the local swimming pool to swim the day away under the warm sun? You'd search the couch cushions in the morning to scrounge together enough spare change to buy an ice cream cone or popcicle of your choice to make the day all that much better. Then you see the sweet action of that Orange Push-Up Pop that can not be denied. That's right, this is the pie that it inspired.
Lazy Day Razzmonade Pie-$16.95
Imagine raspberry lemonade. Now imagine it as a pie.
Coconut Cream Pie-$16.95
Oh my god, I love this pie. Homemade pudding enhanced by shredded coconut and topped with whipped cream made at our store. For some reason it just tastes like Spring to me.
Banana Cream Pie-$16.95
Second verse, same as the first. Banana Cream is much like coconut cream, but definitely for the banana lover. These and the Coconut Cream Pies are made fresh to order, so we slice fresh bananas right in to the pie for that fresh great flavor.
Chocolate Cream Pie-$16.95
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cream Pie-$16.95
Hunka Hunka Burning Pie-$16.95
(Peanut Butter Banana Cream Pie)
Some where, some place, Elvis raising his lip in approval because this pie is TCB.
Peanut Butter Pie-$16.95
Turtle Pie- $18.95
Butter Scotch Cream Pie $16.95
Chocolate Raspberry - $16.95
Double Chocolate - $16.95
Lemon Meringue Pie - $18.95
Grasshopper Pie - $18.95
Custard Style Pies
Old Fashioned Custard Pie - $12.95
"Pop's Favorite" Sour Cream & Raisin - $12.95
If Libby's Pop had one pie to eat for the rest of his life, this would be the one. This old school recipe has come back in a big way in our bakery. With its silky custard filling, infused with beautiful cinnamon and nutmeg, this pie isn't messing around. Step out of your comfort zone and try this classic favorite.
Pumpkin Pie - $12.95
What is Thanksgiving without pumpkin pie? Heck, what is any Fall day without pumpkin pie? Cold and Windy, that's what. And what makes a cold and windy day better? You got it, Pumpkin Pie.
Peacan Crusted Pumpkin Pie - $14.95
Rhubarb Custard Pie - $15.95
Some people say "Why?"...our answer? "Because"
Rhubarb Pie- Just Rhubarb- $14.95
I mean, seriously, we're from Minnesota and we really love our rhubarb here. And this one is for the person that wants pure unadulterated rhubarb pie.
Apple Pie(Seasonal-(Available Summer, Fall and then until they're sold out))- $15.95
Meet the pie that makes Grandma Proud. Made with apples grown from our own trees, we blend them together to achieve the best possible flavor combination we can.
Caramel Apple Pecan Pie -$17.95
(Available Summer, Fall and then until they're sold out)
It's stupid good. I mean seriously, it's so good, it hits you like a ton of bricks and is liable to drop your IQ a couple of points.
More Fruit Pies
Michigan blueberries picked and shipped to us for what makes one truly inspirational creation. We ad blueberries, sugar cinnamon and of course a healthy amount of love.
Miss Sheryl's Blubarb Pie-$15.95
Rich and sweet blueberry's blended to perfection with the tartness with one of Minnesotans favorite ingredient, Rhubarb! Miss Sheryl still work's in the bakery helping Libby perfect this fan favorite.
Caramel Apple - $17.95
(Available Summer, Fall and then until they're sold out)
Strawberry Crumble Pie- $14.95
Red Berry Pie-$14.95
In order to be invited to this party one needs to be a red berry. Blueberries...out, Gooseberries...out, black raspberries...out, Blackberry....out. STRAWBERRIES, CHERRIES, AND CRANBERRIES, YOUR IN!! It's a pretty select group, but they've done it for a reason, they taste great.
Pecan Encrusted Cranberry Pie-$15.95
Have a slice of Holiday Season, ASAP.
CherBarb - (Cherry Rhubarb Pie)-$15.95
"Oh yes we did."
Mixed Berry --$14.95
(Strawberry, Raspberry, & Blueberry)
Much like George Washington, I can not tell a lie. It's tart, it's sweet, it's flaky and it's fabulous.
Everyone knows that strawberries and rhubarb are happy friends. They go to the movies together, sing songs together, and get absolutely delicious together. Join in the friendship.
If we haven't tempted to into a rhubarb style pie yet, we're going to take one last crack at it. Raspberries!!! and rhubarb. Come Onnnn, am I right. Raspberries, there delicious.
Peach Pie -$15.95
French Apple Pie-$15.95
(Seasonal-(Available Summer, Fall and then until they're sold out )
Like it sweet? French apple offers everything our traditional apple does, but with the twist of sweet more from the wonderful crumb crust topping.
"Observe the bumble's one weakness. ... The bumble sinks! Ha ha!". That's right Yukon Cornelius, the Bumble does sink, right into your stomach because it's freakin' awesome.
Experience the south with a wonderful Pecan Pie. Simple. Sweet. Delicious.
Cookie Style Pies
David's Drunken Chocolate Pecan Pie - $16.95
Think sweet and gooey chocolate chip cookie with Pecans and a shot of Maker's Mark bourbon. Sweet, Rich and oh so good, David doesn't shy away from a strong pie.
"Chipmunks Choice" Walnut White Chocolate Chip - $16.95
After endless hours of listening to the Christmas carols of rodents, we decided it was time to make something for "Alvin, Simon...Theodore!". Like Dave's Drunken Pie, this one is got a bit of a sweet and gooey cookie feel, but without the Maker's Mark, it's a bit more chipmunk and kid friendly.
The Cheese Monger's Pie- $16.95
A Simple Cheesecake
Cheese Cake is pie, end of story. It's in the shape of a circle, you cut it into pie wedges. I mean they don't call it a "Cake Chart" do they?
Chocolate Chip Cheesecake- $17.95
Other Delicious Things
Chop Suey Cake- $10.95
Carrot Cake- $12.95
Oatmeal Cake - $10.95