Coconut Cream Pie   $24

Oh my god, I love this pie. Homemade pudding enhanced by shredded coconut and topped with whipped cream made at our store. For some reason it just tastes like Spring to me. 
***Call ahead for availability

Banana Cream Pie   $24

Second verse, same as the first. Banana Cream is much like coconut cream, but definitely for the banana lover. These and the Coconut Cream Pies are made fresh to order, so we slice fresh bananas right in to the pie for that fresh great flavor. 
***Call ahead for availability

Push-Up Pop Pie   $24

Remember those warm Summer days when you used to go to the local swimming pool to swim the day away under the warm sun? You'd search the couch cushions in the morning to scrounge together enough spare change to buy an ice cream cone or popcicle of your choice to make the day all that much better. Then you see the sweet action of that Orange Push-Up Pop that can not be denied. That's right, this is the pie that it inspired.

Stawberry Leomade Pie   $24

Mawage is wot bwings us together today...for pie...STAWBERRY LEMONDADE PIE...and of course wuv, tru wuv!

Stawberry mILKSHAKE Pie   $28

My milkshake brings all the boys to the yard
And they're like, it's better than yours
Damn right it's better than yours!

Chocolate Cream Pie   $24

***Call ahead for availability

Choc. Peanut Butter Cream Pie  $24

***Call ahead for availability

Butter Scotch Cream Pie   $24

***Call ahead for availability

Chocolate Raspberry pie   $24
Double Chocolate Pie   $24
French Silk Pie   $28
Lemon Silk Pie   $24
Grasshopper Pie     $24
Pink Squirrel     $24
Keylime & Coconut     $24

Key Lime Pie   $24

Make the trip to the Florida Key's without leaving the state. This creamy pie has a wonderful twist of of Key Lime Juice that for a great sweet and tart combination. Topped with homemade whipped cream, you won't be disappointed. 

BUTTERSCOTCH TWIST   $24

cHOCOLATE pEANUT bUTTER cUP  $24

Custard Style

Old Fashioned Custard Pie  $15

"Pop's Favorite" Sour Cream & Raisin  $15

If Libby's Pop had one pie to eat for the rest of his life, this would be the one.  This old school recipe has come back in a big way in our bakery. With its silky custard filling, infused with beautiful cinnamon and nutmeg, this pie isn't messing around. Step out of your comfort zone and try this classic favorite.

tHE brunchie $15

Sour Cream and Cranberry...wait, what? That's right we did it and it's great.

Pumpkin Pie  $15

What is Thanksgiving without pumpkin pie? Heck, what is any Fall day without pumpkin pie? Cold and Windy, that's what. And what makes a cold and windy day better? You got it, Pumpkin Pie.

Pecan Crusted Pumpkin Pie  $18

10% better than the last one...(i just dropped the mic)

Rhubarb Custard Pie  $22

Some people say "Why?"...our answer? "Because"

Pecan Pie  $25

Experience the south with a wonderful Pecan Pie. Simple. Sweet. Delicious.
**Seasonal availability on some pies, please call the store for information on availability